Used Ford F-150 vs. Used Chevrolet Silverado 1500: Which Full-Size Truck Is Best for You?
When it comes to buying a pre-owned full-size pickup truck in Arizona, two names stand out above the rest: the Ford F-150 and the Chevrolet Silverado 1500. Both trucks are well-regarded for their durability, performance, and features, but which one is right for your needs in 2025? This comparison dives deep into pricing, performance, towing, reliability, and Arizona-specific factors like desert climate suitability.
Overview: Why These Trucks Dominate the Market
The Ford F-150 has long been America’s best-selling truck for a reason—strong engine options, excellent towing capacity, and a wide array of trims. The Chevrolet Silverado 1500, meanwhile, matches or exceeds the F-150 in key areas like ride comfort, technology, and trailering technology.
In Arizona, these trucks are especially appealing due to their ability to handle hot weather, long-distance drives, and off-road terrain. Whether you’re hauling construction gear in Mesa or heading to a campsite near Payson, you’ll need a truck that can handle the heat—literally and figuratively.
Performance & Towing Capacity
Ford F-150
- Multiple engine choices, including a 2.7L EcoBoost V6 and a 5.0L V8
- Towing capacity up to 13,000 lbs (depending on configuration)
- 10-speed automatic transmission across most trims
Chevrolet Silverado 1500
- Engines range from a 2.7L turbocharged 4-cylinder to a 6.2L V8
- Towing capacity up to 13,300 lbs (when properly equipped)
- Available Multi-Flex tailgate and advanced trailering camera systems
Verdict: For buyers focused on maximum towing, the Silverado 1500 has a slight edge, but the F-150’s EcoBoost options offer a better blend of power and fuel economy for daily driving in Phoenix and surrounding areas.
Interior Features & Technology
Both trucks offer premium options like leather upholstery, dual-zone climate control, and large touchscreen infotainment systems. In Arizona’s extreme summer heat, comfort features like ventilated seats and dual-zone AC are more than just luxuries—they’re necessities.
Notable Features:
- F-150: SYNC 4 system, digital instrument cluster, fold-flat work surface
- Silverado 1500: Google built-in, 13.4-inch touchscreen, Super Cruise (on higher trims)
Verdict: The Silverado 1500 edges ahead with tech, especially if you’re considering newer models. However, used F-150s tend to retain more value in the Arizona market according to recent resale value trends.
Fuel Economy
Fuel economy is increasingly important, especially with the fluctuating gas prices in Arizona. Both trucks offer fuel-efficient engines, but the F-150’s EcoBoost options deliver better MPG without sacrificing performance.
Estimated Fuel Economy (2021–2023 models):
- F-150 2.7L EcoBoost: 20 city / 26 highway
- Silverado 1500 2.7L Turbo: 19 city / 22 highway
Verdict: The Ford F-150 wins in fuel efficiency, especially if you’re commuting between Mesa, Chandler, and Phoenix.
Reliability & Maintenance in Arizona
In Arizona’s hot, dry conditions, trucks need strong cooling systems and proven reliability. The F-150 has a long-standing reputation for dependability. However, newer Silverados with the 5.3L V8 have also shown fewer issues in recent consumer reports.
Both trucks benefit from being popular in the Southwest, meaning parts and service are readily available at competitive prices.
Verdict: It’s a tie on reliability, but used F-150s tend to have lower long-term repair costs in Arizona climates.
Pricing & Value
Used Pricing Averages (Arizona market, 2021–2023 models):
- F-150: $32,000–$48,000 (varies by trim/miles)
- Silverado 1500: $31,000–$47,000 (varies by trim/miles)
Used truck specials in Mesa often include incentives like extended warranties or no-payment-for-90-days financing. Make sure to check for offers on both models.
Arizona-Specific Considerations
- Desert Driving: Silverado’s ride is smoother over rough roads. F-150 has better off-road packages (Tremor, FX4).
- Summer Heat: Both trucks include heavy-duty cooling systems, but always test AC performance on idle in 100+ degree conditions.
- Registration Fees: F-150 sometimes offers slightly lower VLT (Vehicle License Tax) due to resale depreciation curves.
Financing Options in Arizona
Whether you choose Ford or Chevy, you can explore affordable financing options through Arizona Car Sales. We’re a Credit Union Direct Lending Plus dealer, giving you access to low rates, flexible terms, and no payments for 90 days on approved credit.
Which One Should You Choose?
If you’re looking for:
- More towing and advanced trailering tech: Go with the Silverado 1500
- Better fuel economy and resale value: Choose the F-150
- Arizona off-road capability: Ford F-150 Tremor or FX4 trims win here
- Latest cabin tech and screen size: Silverado LTZ or High Country
No matter which truck you choose, Arizona Car Sales has a great selection of quality pre-owned trucks that meet your budget and lifestyle.
Why Buy from Arizona Car Sales?
At Arizona Car Sales, we prioritize your peace of mind and satisfaction. Every vehicle on our lot undergoes a rigorous 120+ point safety inspection, ensuring it meets Arizona state safety requirements and exceeds your expectations for quality and reliability. We provide a free vehicle history report on every vehicle, so you can buy with confidence. With thousands of 5-star reviews, a no-pressure experience, and no hidden fees, it’s no wonder Arizona Car Sales is the trusted choice for pre-owned trucks in Phoenix, Mesa, and beyond.
Related Blog Posts
- Used Toyota Camry vs. Used Honda Accord
- Used Toyota RAV4 vs. Used Honda CR-V
- Affordable Trucks for Work and Play in Phoenix
- Best Used Cars That Can Tow 4000 lbs or More
0 comment(s) so far on Used Ford F-150 vs. Used Chevrolet Silverado 1500: Which Full-Size Truck Is Best for You?