Which Used Cars Are the Most Reliable?

July 29th, 2024 by

When you’re buying a used car, many factors come into play: price, features, color, and style. But for the savvy buyer, one word stands above all others as the true measure of a great purchase: reliability. A car that starts every single time, requires minimal unscheduled repairs, and gives you complete confidence on the road is worth its weight in gold. Yet, with thousands of used vehicles for sale across Phoenix, how can you be sure you’re choosing a dependable model and not investing your hard-earned money into someone else’s problems?

The consequences of owning an unreliable car in Arizona are more severe than in other parts of the country. It’s not just the frustration of a check engine light or the cost of a surprise repair bill. It’s the very real stress of your car’s air conditioning failing during a 115-degree afternoon commute, the danger of breaking down on a dark stretch of highway, or the fear of being stranded anywhere in our extreme climate. Your vehicle’s dependability is directly linked to your safety and peace of mind.

This guide is here to replace that uncertainty with confidence. Modern automotive reliability isn’t a matter of luck or guesswork; it’s a measurable science tracked by world-renowned organizations. We’ve analyzed the data from the experts to create a definitive report on the most reliable used cars you can buy in 2025. This is your shopping list for the brands and specific models that have proven, year after year, to be the champions of dependability—the perfect choices for any Arizona driver.

Table of Contents

  • How is Reliability Measured? A Look at the Experts
  • The Kings of Reliability: The Brands to Trust
  • The A-List: 5 of the Most Reliable Used Models You Can Buy
  • Shop with Confidence in Mesa, AZ
  • Why Arizona Car Sales Is Your Best Option for Reliable Vehicles

How is Reliability Measured? A Look at the Experts

Before diving into the list, it’s important to know where this information comes from. Our recommendations aren’t based on our opinion; they’re based on decades of exhaustive data from two of the most trusted names in the automotive industry:

  • Consumer Reports: This independent, non-profit organization conducts extensive vehicle testing and, most importantly, gathers detailed annual survey data from hundreds of thousands of real car owners about the problems they’ve experienced with their vehicles. This real-world feedback is used to generate a “predicted reliability” score for various makes and models.
  • J.D. Power: A global leader in consumer insights, J.D. Power conducts its annual Vehicle Dependability Study (VDS), which measures the number of problems per 100 vehicles experienced during the past 12 months by original owners of 3-year-old vehicles. A lower score means fewer problems and higher reliability.

When brands and models consistently receive top marks from both of these organizations, it’s a powerful indicator of their long-term quality and durability.

The Kings of Reliability: The Brands to Trust

Year after year, the same names dominate the top of the reliability charts. While almost every brand makes a decent car today, these manufacturers have built their entire reputation on exceptional quality control and engineering that stands the test of time. When in doubt, starting your search with these brands is always a smart move.

  • Toyota & Lexus: Toyota and its luxury division, Lexus, are the undisputed champions of reliability. They are consistently ranked #1 and #2 by nearly every major publication. Their obsession with quality manufacturing results in vehicles that are famous for running for hundreds of thousands of miles with just basic maintenance.
  • Honda & Acura: Following closely behind Toyota, Honda and its luxury brand Acura have a legendary reputation for building durable engines and transmissions. They combine this reliability with a fun-to-drive nature and smart interior packaging.
  • Other Consistent High-Performers: Brands like Subaru (known for its standard AWD and durable build) and Mazda (known for its sporty driving dynamics and reliable components) also frequently appear in the top rankings.

The A-List: 5 of the Most Reliable Used Models You Can Buy

While the brands above are great starting points, these five specific models are consistently cited as being among the most dependable used vehicles you can purchase. They are the A-listers of the reliability world.

1. The Toyota Camry: The Definition of Dependable

Why It’s So Reliable: The Camry is the gold standard for a no-nonsense, “it just works” family sedan. Its design philosophy prioritizes longevity and ease of ownership over flashy trends. This focus has resulted in a vehicle that is virtually synonymous with reliability, consistently earning top marks from both Consumer Reports and J.D. Power for its low number of owner-reported problems and its ability to last for well over 200,000 miles with minimal fuss.

What to Look For: While almost any generation is a safe bet, models from 2018-2024 are particularly strong, offering modern safety features and technology alongside the classic Camry dependability.

Arizona Pro-Tip: The Camry’s robust and straightforward air conditioning system is well-known for being highly effective and durable, a crucial feature for handling the brutal Phoenix summers without issue.

2. The Honda Civic: The Unstoppable Compact

Why It’s So Reliable: The Honda Civic has built a multi-generational legacy on being an affordable, fuel-efficient, and incredibly durable compact car. Honda’s expertise in engineering small, efficient, and high-revving four-cylinder engines is legendary. This results in a powertrain that is not only fun and economical but also famously under-stressed, leading to remarkable longevity and low long-term maintenance costs.

What to Look For: The tenth generation (2016-2021) is often cited as a high point, offering a huge leap in interior quality, technology, and refined driving dynamics while maintaining the reliability the model is famous for.

Arizona Pro-Tip: Its excellent fuel efficiency makes it a perfect choice for navigating the ever-expanding sprawl of the East Valley, saving you money on long commutes from Mesa to Scottsdale or Chandler.

3. The Toyota 4Runner: The Indestructible SUV

Why It’s So Reliable: The 4Runner is a bit of a legend. It’s a true body-on-frame SUV built on a truck platform, and it’s engineered with a focus on simplicity and toughness over complex, fragile technology. Its tried-and-true V6 engine and robust 4×4 system are known for being able to withstand incredible amounts of use and abuse. It’s not uncommon to see 4Runners with 250,000 or even 300,000 miles still competently tackling Arizona’s toughest off-road trails.

What to Look For: The fifth generation has been in production for over a decade (since 2010), meaning Toyota has had years to perfect the platform. Any model from this generation is considered a very safe bet.

Arizona Pro-Tip: If your weekends involve heading north to the high country or exploring remote desert trails, the 4Runner’s legendary durability provides the ultimate peace of mind when you’re miles from the nearest paved road.

4. The Honda CR-V: The Sensible SUV Benchmark

Why It’s So Reliable: For those who don’t need the extreme off-road capability of a 4Runner, the Honda CR-V is the sensible, smart, and ultra-reliable choice. It perfectly blends the efficiency and comfort of a sedan with the practicality of an SUV. Like the Civic, its powertrain is designed for longevity, and its interior is built with high-quality materials that hold up well over time. It consistently ranks at the very top of its class for both reliability and low ownership costs.

What to Look For: The 2017-2022 generation is a fantastic choice, offering a spacious interior and the introduction of an efficient turbocharged engine.

Arizona Pro-Tip: The CR-V’s practical, versatile interior is perfect for the East Valley family lifestyle, easily swallowing everything from sports gear for a tournament in Gilbert to a week’s worth of groceries.

5. The Toyota Tacoma: The Legend of Durability

Why It’s So Reliable: The Toyota Tacoma’s reputation is built on a simple promise: it will not let you down. Prized by everyone from contractors to off-road adventurers, the Tacoma is famous for its rugged build quality and its ability to keep going, no matter the conditions. This reputation for being unkillable is the primary reason it also has the best resale value of any truck on the market, making it both a reliable and financially sound investment.

What to Look For: The third generation (2016-2023) is known for its improved interior and powerful V6 engine. The TRD Off-Road models are particularly sought-after for their enhanced capability.

Arizona Pro-Tip: In a state where trucks are a way of life, the Tacoma is the undisputed king of its class for holding up to the work, heat, and recreational demands of any Arizona truck owner.

Shop with Confidence in Mesa, AZ

Choosing a reliable used car is the smartest decision you can make, and your search should start with proven models like these. At Arizona Car Sales, we make it a priority to stock our inventory with high-quality, dependable vehicles that we know our customers will be happy with for years to come. Every car on our lot goes through a rigorous inspection process to ensure it meets our high standards.

Take the next step in your search for a dependable vehicle. Explore our inventory of top-rated brands online and learn more about our commitment to quality.

View Our Most Reliable ModelsLearn About Our Inspection Process

Why Arizona Car Sales Is Your Best Option for Reliable Vehicles

At Arizona Car Sales, we specialize in delivering quality pre-owned vehicles at competitive prices. Our inventory includes vehicles that have passed rigorous inspections, and we provide transparent vehicle history reports for every car on the lot. With thousands of five-star reviews, an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, and the distinction of being a two-time “Top Dealer” winner on CarGurus, you can trust us to provide an exceptional car-buying experience. We also offer financing options tailored to your budget, ensuring you can drive home your dream car with confidence.

Related Blog Posts:

Serving All East Valley Communities: Your Local Used Car Hub

Arizona Car Sales is proud to be the trusted used car resource for your specific East Valley community. Click on your city below to learn more about our tailored services and inventory for your area:

most reliable used cars, reliable cars arizona, dependable used cars phoenix, best used cars to buy, cars that last 200k miles, used toyota reliability, used honda reliability, best used suvs for reliability, reliable trucks arizona, what used car should i buy, consumer reports best used cars, jd power reliability, arizona car sales reliable, used cars that won’t break down
Posted in Arizona Car Sales, Used vehicles